The fit on LL Bean's shirts has varied tremendously from item to item, but they got it right with the Black Point Polo [$39]. Trim in the torso, good sleeve proportions, and the right overall length to wear untucked. That said, while polos are never particularly dressy, this one's made from a washed lightweight jersey that feels t-shirtesque (that's a word we just made up). The spread self-collar is a nice design idea but due to the material will never lie smoothly no matter how much you steam it. Choose something like this in place of a t-shirt, but not over a more refined polo.